Dicipline that Works


With Kieran, positive reinforcement is key.

He really does not respond to other types of discipline, especially tough love.

I remember one time that I said how disappointed I was with a choice he made.

He proceeded to cry and share how unloveable he was.

I was stopped in my tracks.

I took it all back.

I wound up apologizing to him.

Not only had he taking my words seriously, he took them too seriously.

He did another thing as well.

He noted my response…

The next time we were in a similar situation, even though I tread lightly, he immediately brought out the “unlovable” argument.

He was manipulating me!

I learned my lesson.

In sixth grade, I also learned an important lesson about what doesn’t work with my child.

My tipping point of defending him, instead of acknowledging his mistake.

One of his teachers, frustrated with his behavior (and rightly frustrated), asked Kieran in front of the class if he needed to be brought to my office (which was located adjacent to his school) in order to listen.

Not only was this lesson and his behavior lost on Kieran, he was so embarrassed that he wound up losing trust in the teacher for a while.

He literally saw red when he explained to me what happened.

If he had been approached privately, he might have been penitent.

I learned that when I need to address Kieran, I will have more success in redirecting his behavior, appealing to his logical mind, or asking him for a favor.

Tough love is too tough for this sensitive kid.

7 thoughts on “Dicipline that Works

  1. Some kids just can not take confrontation of any kind (that was my younger son), so it always had to be private discussions, and even that was not always the right approach. Every child is different, eh?! Parenting takes so much energy (but having just spent 3 days with my 26-year old), but it gives energy too!

  2. It is amazing and a real learning process to see how differently each child responds to our methods. As a mother of four, I have to say that I am a different mother to each. They all need something different from me in their struggles if I am to actually help them on their way. I appreciate you sharing your experience, so we can learn more of how unique our approach needs to be.

  3. Just as every student has his or her own unique way of learning each also has an approach to discipline that works for them. You pointed out so well that we cannot administer cookie cutter discipline just as we cannot use cookie cutter instruction with all students. It is so important that we know our students. Happy New Year to you and your family.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s